Comparison

Data broker vs data aggregator

Data broker vs data aggregator: one sells or licenses information to others, the other gathers and combines it from many sources.

By

Published

The short answer

A data aggregator gathers information from many sources and combines it into one set; a data broker sells or licenses information to others. Many large consumer data brokers are also aggregators, but the roles differ. Brokering is about the transaction, aggregation is about assembly, and US laws define and regulate each in different contexts.

Two verbs, not two industries

The easiest way to keep the terms apart is to look at the verb behind each. Aggregating means collecting pieces from many places and combining them. Brokering means arranging a sale between someone who has something and someone who wants it.

A company can do one, the other, or both, and the labels say nothing about size: some aggregators are giant consumer data firms, and some brokers are one person working on commission.

Why the terms blur

The confusion comes from the biggest firms doing both at once. The FTC's 2014 study of nine data brokers found they obtained most of their data from other data brokers rather than from original sources, combined it into profiles, and sold the results.

In that part of the market, aggregation is how the product is built and brokering is how it is sold.

Aggregation builds the product; brokering sells it. Some firms do both, some only one. From the side-by-side table on this page.

Side by side

Compiled from the FTC's 2014 report, California's data broker registry and 12 CFR 1033.131. Simplified; many firms span both columns.
Data brokerData aggregator
Core activitySells, licenses or arranges the sale of data to othersCollects data from many sources and combines it
Holds the data?Often, but an intermediary broker may never store itYes; the combined set is the work
Typical sourcesIts own collection, other brokers, or a client company's dataPublic records, partners, APIs, other providers, accounts the user connects
Typical customersMarketers, risk and fraud teams, AI labs, analystsApps, analysts, and the brokers who resell the combined set
US rule that names itState registry laws, such as California's Delete Act registryIn finance, the CFPB's Section 1033 rule defines a data aggregator
ExampleA firm licensing consumer segments; a broker placing a company's codebase with an AI labA service that pulls a person's bank data into a budgeting app; a news aggregator

What the law means by each

Data broker in state law

California's privacy agency describes a data broker as a business that collects personal information about consumers from various sources and sells it to other companies, even when the consumer never dealt with that business. Those businesses must register with the state every January. The definition turns on selling personal information without a direct relationship, not on aggregating as such.

Data aggregator in the CFPB rule

The term data aggregator shows up most clearly in US financial regulation. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's personal financial data rights rule, 12 CFR 1033.131, defines a data aggregator as a person retained by an authorized third party to enable access to covered financial data.

In that sense an aggregator is a service provider connecting apps to bank accounts at a consumer's request, a very different role from a broker selling profiles. The rule has been under reconsideration, so check its current status before relying on it.

Where the roles overlap

  • Consumer data firms aggregate records from public sources and other brokers, then sell segments or lookups. They are both at once, which is why the words are used interchangeably in the press.
  • People-search sites aggregate public records and broker access to the results, and appear on state registries as data brokers.
  • Alternative-data providers aggregate signals such as prices or shipping records, package them and license them to investors.

Where they differ

Where they clearly differ is at the edges. A financial data aggregator that moves a customer's own bank data into an app, at the customer's request, isn't selling that data to anyone.

And a broker who arranges a licence between a company that owns a dataset and an AI lab never aggregates anything; the dataset already exists, and the broker's work is finding both sides and getting the deal signed.

Which one is the job people mean by becoming a data broker

Most people searching for how to become a data broker do not want to build an aggregation pipeline, which needs collection infrastructure, compliance staff and registrations. They want the intermediary role: finding companies that hold data buyers want, checking the rights, valuing it, and closing a licence for a commission. That is the job the DataBroker academy teaches.

  1. 1

    Decide which role you are taking

    If you will collect and combine data yourself, you are building an aggregator and may need to register as a data broker. If you will arrange deals for owners, you are an intermediary.

  2. 2

    Check whether personal data is involved

    Registry laws mostly turn on selling personal information about consumers. Business data and de-identified company records usually sit outside them, but check.

  3. 3

    Put your role in writing

    A broker agreement with the owner sets out what you do, what you are paid and that the owner holds the rights. It keeps the roles clear for buyers too.

More about data broker vs data aggregator

Limits of this comparison

Sources

3 sources · checked Nov 7, 2026

The DataBroker team checked the facts on this page against 3 public sources, last on .

  1. FTC, Data Brokers: A Call for Transparency and Accountability, May 2014Nine brokers studied; most data obtained from other brokers; seven of nine supply each other · Checked
  2. California Privacy Protection Agency, data broker registryPlain-language data broker definition; annual January registration · Checked
  3. 12 CFR 1033.131, via Cornell LIIDefinition of data aggregator in the CFPB's personal financial data rights rule · Checked

Data broker vs data aggregator FAQ

Is a data aggregator the same as a data broker?

Not exactly. An aggregator combines data from many sources; a broker sells or licenses data to others. Many large consumer data firms do both, which is why the terms get mixed up, but either can exist without the other.

Is Plaid a data broker or a data aggregator?

Services that connect a person's bank accounts to apps at that person's request are usually called financial data aggregators, which is the role the CFPB's Section 1033 rule defines. Whether any specific company also counts as a data broker under a state law depends on what it sells.

Do data aggregators have to register like data brokers?

Only if they also meet a state's data broker definition, which generally means selling personal information about consumers they have no direct relationship with. Aggregation alone isn't the test.

Can a data broker work without aggregating data?

Yes. An intermediary broker can arrange a licence between a company that already owns a dataset and a buyer without collecting or combining anything, and be paid a commission under a broker agreement with the owner.

Related

  • Data broker

    The data broker definition in plain words and in state law, the six kinds of data broker, and the rules each kind answers to.

  • The DataBroker NDA generator with a one-way agreement between Acme Analytics LLC and Northwind Research Inc. filled in, and its numbered clauses previewed beside the form.
    How to become a data broker

    How to become a data broker who brings company datasets to buyers: the skills, the legal checks, the documents and the order you do them in.

  • Is selling data legal?

    Is selling data legal? A plain look at when a sale is allowed, when registration applies, and when to call a lawyer first.

Join the DataBroker academy

The DataBroker academy and tools: find companies with data to sell, price it, license it and close the deal.