Leads

Exclusive leads: what they cost and when they beat shared

Exclusive leads go to one buyer only, cost more per lead, and pay back only when contact rates and deal value are high enough.

By

Published

Exclusive, semi-exclusive and shared

An exclusive lead is delivered to one buyer and no one else. A shared lead is sold to several buyers at once, most often three to seven according to Lead Gen Economy, sometimes more. Semi-exclusive sits between, with two or three.

Buyers per exclusive lead
one
Buyers per semi-exclusive lead
two or three
Buyers per shared lead, most often (Lead Gen Economy)
three to seven

The person behind the lead is the same; what changes is how many companies call them in the next ten minutes.

The premium, vertical by vertical

Contact rate, exclusive leads
60% to 80%
Contact rate, shared leads
40% to 60%
Compiled by DataBroker from Lead Gen Economy's comparison (updated March 2026). Third-party figures, not our prices.
VerticalSharedExclusivePremium
Auto insurance$15 to $25$55 to $752.5 to 3x
Home insurance$20 to $35$60 to $1002 to 3x
Life insurance$25 to $45$75 to $1502.5 to 3.5x
Mortgage (purchase)$20 to $50$50 to $3002 to 6x
Solar$40 to $80$95 to $1502 to 2.5x
Personal injury$60 to $150$200 to $400+2.5 to 4x
Family law$30 to $90$100 to $3002.5 to 3.5x

The same source reports contact rates of 60% to 80% for exclusive leads against 40% to 60% for shared, and says exclusive leads convert 15% to 40% better than shared leads of similar quality. Those are vendor figures; your buyers' own numbers are the ones that matter.

Doing the sum per contact, not per lead

Elevarus published a life insurance example that shows why the headline gap overstates the difference. A $22 shared lead reached at a 40% contact rate costs $55 per conversation. A $90 exclusive lead reached 85% of the time costs about $106. A fourfold difference in price becomes roughly twofold per contact.

A fourfold price gap becomes roughly twofold per contact (Elevarus's life insurance example).
Per conversation: a $22 shared lead at 40% contact
$55
Per conversation: a $90 exclusive lead at 85% contact
about $106
Source: Elevarus, listed under Sources.
  1. 1

    Work out the ceiling

    Maximum profitable cost per lead = gross profit per sale × lead-to-sale conversion rate. Elevarus's term life example: $250 profit × 8% = about $20.

  2. 2

    Compare per contact

    Divide each price by its contact rate. This is where exclusive leads close most of the gap.

  3. 3

    Check the buyer's speed

    Exclusive leads pay back mainly for buyers who call within seconds. Elevarus's rule of thumb for life insurance put the breakeven near $1,400 of annual premium per policy, assuming sub-90-second dialling.

What exclusive should mean in the contract

  • No other buyer receives the record, in real time or later.
  • How long exclusivity lasts, and whether the record may ever be resold as an aged lead.
  • Consent text that names this buyer, so the buyer can lawfully call. The FCC's one-to-one rule was vacated in January 2025, but naming one seller is still the cleanest evidence.
  • A returns policy for duplicates, wrong numbers and records the buyer already held.
  • Audit rights: a consent certificate or session record for each lead.

Red flags

  • Exclusive leads priced like shared ones.
  • Consumers who say several companies called them.
  • A seller who won't put the exclusivity period in writing.
  • Exclusive forms with a long list of partner companies in the consent text.

Where DataBroker stands

We don't sell exclusive or shared leads. DataBroker is a paid academy and a set of tools for brokers deciding how to package and price lead supply: which buyers will pay an exclusivity premium, how to model it per contact, and how to write the terms so both sides can check them.

Sources

5 sources · checked Nov 7, 2026

Exclusive leads FAQ

Are exclusive leads worth the extra cost?

Only when the buyer calls fast and each sale is valuable. Per contact the gap narrows to roughly twofold in one published example, so higher-value products and quick follow-up tip the balance toward exclusive.

How much more do exclusive leads cost than shared?

Usually two to three times more. One published comparison shows premiums from 2x in solar and home insurance to as much as 6x in purchase mortgage leads.

Can an exclusive lead be resold later?

Only if the contract allows it. Many sellers resell exclusive leads as aged leads after a period, so buyers should ask and get the answer in writing.

What is a semi-exclusive lead?

A lead sold to two or three buyers, priced between shared and exclusive. It is a compromise for buyers who want fewer competitors without paying the full premium.

Related

  • Aged leads

    Aged leads are older inquiries resold at a discount; this page shows how price falls with age and why consent decides their value.

  • Solar leads

    Solar leads range from cheap aged records to booked in-home appointments, and installers price each stage very differently.

  • Life insurance leads

    Life insurance leads are inquiries from people shopping for cover; here is how agents buy them, what they cost and which rules apply.

  • Personal injury leads

    Personal injury leads are priced by case type and contact method, and solicitation laws make some supply sources criminal.

Join the DataBroker academy

The DataBroker academy and tools: find companies with data to sell, price it, license it and close the deal.