Leads
Auto insurance leads: how they are priced and sold
Auto insurance leads are drivers requesting quotes; this guide covers which agencies buy them, published prices, consent and common traps.
Published
What is an auto insurance lead?
An auto insurance lead is a driver's request for a car insurance quote, carrying details such as vehicles, drivers and current insurer, sold to carriers, captive agents or independent agencies that will quote it.
A high-volume, low-price vertical
Everyone with a car has to carry insurance, and many drivers shop at renewal, so auto produces more leads than any other personal line. That volume pushes prices down.
A single quote form often sells to several buyers within seconds through a ping-post auction, where the generator 'pings' buyers with anonymised details and sells the full record to the highest bidder.
Who the buyers are
Buyers include carriers' direct-response teams, captive agents of the large brands, independent agencies that can quote many carriers, and comparison sites that resell to all three. Each wants different filters: some only want drivers with continuous prior coverage, others want high-risk drivers that standard carriers decline.
Published auto lead prices
- Shared web form (Phonexa)
- $2–$12
- Shared web form (ActiveProspect)
- about $10–$25
- Pay-per-call (Phonexa)
- $20–$80
| Format | Phonexa (March 2026) | ActiveProspect (Sept 2026) |
|---|---|---|
| Shared web form | $2–$12 | about $10–$25 |
| High-quality or exclusive web form | $8–$16 (high quality) | about $30–$80 (exclusive) |
| Pay-per-call | $20–$80 | not given |
| Live transfer | $45–$120 with a duration requirement; $60–$150 exclusive | about $50–$150 |
Why the two lists differ
The two lists diverge most on web forms. That gap is real in the market: an unfiltered shared form and a filtered exclusive one are different products that happen to share a name. When you broker auto leads, write down the filters and the number of buyers per record in the contract, or the price means nothing.
How quote forms create consent
Most auto leads begin on a multi-step quote form. The final step usually carries the consent statement next to the submit button. For autodialed or prerecorded calls and texts, the TCPA requires prior express written consent naming the seller.
The vacated one-to-one rule
The FCC's 2023 one-to-one rule, which would have required a separate consent for each seller, was vacated by the Eleventh Circuit in January 2025 in a case brought by an insurance marketing trade group.
What buyers check on the form
A buyer will ask whether its own name appeared on the form. If the disclosure said 'and our partners', with partners in a linked list of hundreds of companies, many buyers now refuse the lead, and plaintiffs' lawyers treat that kind of consent as weak.
Rules beyond the TCPA
- State insurance producer licensing: quoting or discussing coverage generally requires a licence in the driver's state; collecting interest usually does not.
- Florida limits solicitation calls to 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. and three per 24 hours on one subject; Oklahoma requires written consent for automated calls.
- Do Not Call scrubbing, with lists refreshed at least every 31 days for the Telemarketing Sales Rule safe harbour.
- CAN-SPAM for any email follow-up: honest headers and subject lines, a physical address and a working opt-out honoured within 10 business days.
Traps specific to auto
- Recycled forms: the same driver submitted again under a new timestamp to sell twice.
- Incentivised traffic, where people fill in quote forms to earn rewards rather than to buy insurance.
- Bot-completed forms with plausible but invented vehicles.
- Transfers counted as billable after a few seconds of hold music.
What DataBroker offers here
DataBroker doesn't generate or resell auto insurance leads. It is a paid academy with tools for people building a business arranging data and lead deals between companies. For auto, that means knowing how ping-post pricing works, what filters to put in writing, and how to check a generator's consent capture before you introduce it to an agency.
Sources
8 sources · checked Nov 7, 2026
The DataBroker team checked the facts on this page against 8 public sources, last on .
- Insurance Leads Cost: Complete Pricing Breakdown, Phonexa, 31 March 2026Checked
- Insurance leads cost: How much does it cost to buy leads in the insurance industry?, ActiveProspect, 28 September 2026Checked
- 47 CFR 64.1200, Delivery restrictions (TCPA rules), eCFRChecked
- Eleventh Circuit Vacates FCC's TCPA One-to-One Consent Rule, Morrison Foerster, 30 January 2025Checked
- Florida's New Mini-TCPA: What You Need to Know, Holland & Knight, 14 July 2021Checked
- Oklahoma's Mini-TCPA Takes Effect, ManattChecked
- 16 CFR 310.4, Abusive telemarketing acts or practices (Telemarketing Sales Rule), eCFRChecked
- CAN-SPAM Act: A Compliance Guide for Business, Federal Trade CommissionChecked
Auto insurance leads FAQ
How much do auto insurance leads cost?
Published ranges start around $2 to $25 for shared web leads, rise to about $30 to $80 for exclusive ones, and reach $45 to $150 for live transfers.
What is ping-post in auto insurance leads?
An auction where the generator sends buyers a partial record, collects bids, and sells the full contact to the winner or winners. It is the usual way shared auto leads are sold.
Who buys auto insurance leads?
Carriers' direct teams, captive agents of national brands, independent agencies and comparison sites that resell to them.
Related
- Health insurance leads
Health insurance leads are consumers shopping for individual or family cover; this page explains seasons, prices and the consent rules CMS enforces.
- Life insurance leads
Life insurance leads are inquiries from people shopping for cover; here is how agents buy them, what they cost and which rules apply.
- Aged leads
Aged leads are older inquiries resold at a discount; this page shows how price falls with age and why consent decides their value.
Join the DataBroker academy
The DataBroker academy and tools: find companies with data to sell, price it, license it and close the deal.







