Leads

Health insurance leads: the ACA rules and what agents pay

Health insurance leads are consumers shopping for individual or family cover; this page explains seasons, prices and the consent rules CMS enforces.

By

Published

What is a health insurance lead?

A health insurance lead is a consumer's request for help choosing individual, family or small-group health cover, often on the ACA Marketplace, sold to licensed health agents and brokers.

Seasonal demand and who pays

Health leads follow the calendar. Most individual cover is bought during the annual open enrollment window in late autumn and winter, with a trickle of special-enrollment shoppers the rest of the year after a job loss, move or birth.

Buyers are agencies that enroll consumers in ACA Marketplace plans, agents who also sell short-term and supplemental products, and call centres working for carriers.

Why health buyers are strict

The Marketplace pays agents through carriers, and CMS can suspend an agent's ability to enroll consumers. That makes health buyers unusually strict about lead quality: one bad source can put an agency's whole Marketplace business at risk.

Published prices

Shared web form
$2–$18
ACA web form in peak season
$8–$15
Live transfer
$65–$110
From Phonexa's March 2026 insurance pricing breakdown; per lead or per call, US.
FormatPublished range
Shared web form$2–$18
ACA web form in peak season$8–$15
Live transfer$65–$110
Pay-per-call$35–$120

Only one source we checked broke out health prices separately, so treat the table as one platform's view rather than a market average. Prices rise during open enrollment, when every agency is buying at once, and fall sharply after it closes.

Marketplace, short-term and supplemental leads are not interchangeable

A consumer who asked about subsidised Marketplace cover is a poor fit for an agent who mainly sells short-term medical or hospital indemnity plans, and the reverse is true too.

Good generators tag each record with the product the person asked about, household size and income band, because those fields decide whether the consumer qualifies for premium tax credits.

Make the product tag part of the spec

When you broker health leads, make the product tag part of the specification: a buyer who receives the wrong kind of inquiry will reject it, and a consumer steered from a subsidised plan into a product that doesn't meet ACA standards is exactly the outcome regulators look for.

Special-enrollment leads

Special-enrollment leads deserve their own price and filter. Outside the open window, a consumer can only enroll after a qualifying life event, so a record that doesn't capture the event is often unworkable until the next season.

Red flags in health lead sources

  • Ads offering 'free money' or cash cards for signing up, which have been tied to unauthorised enrollments.
  • Leads where the consumer already has Medicaid or Medicare and isn't eligible for a Marketplace plan.
  • Transfers that skip the consumer's own agreement to work with the agent.
  • Sources that resell the same consumer to many agencies during open enrollment.

How DataBroker relates to this

DataBroker is not an enrollment platform and has no health leads to sell. It is a paid training programme with software for brokers of data and lead deals. In a vertical as regulated as this, the academy's value is in the vetting: knowing which records a buyer's compliance team will ask for and refusing sources that can't produce them.

Sources

4 sources · checked Nov 7, 2026

Health insurance leads FAQ

How much do health insurance leads cost?

Phonexa lists shared health web leads at $2 to $18, peak-season ACA forms at $8 to $15, live transfers at $65 to $110 and pay-per-call at $35 to $120.

Does a lead form count as CMS consent?

Broker summaries of the CMS rule say no. The enrolling agent must document the consumer's own consent before helping them on the Marketplace.

When are health insurance leads most expensive?

During annual open enrollment, when most individual cover is bought and many agencies compete for the same consumers.

Related

  • Medicare leads

    Medicare leads come from beneficiaries asking about Advantage, supplement or drug plans, and CMS rules limit how they may be passed on.

  • Auto insurance leads

    Auto insurance leads are drivers requesting quotes; this guide covers which agencies buy them, published prices, consent and common traps.

  • Life insurance leads

    Life insurance leads are inquiries from people shopping for cover; here is how agents buy them, what they cost and which rules apply.

  • How to buy leads

    To buy leads that turn into customers, choose the right source type, check the consent behind each record and agree returns first.

Join the DataBroker academy

The DataBroker academy and tools: find companies with data to sell, price it, license it and close the deal.